Peter Pan (Fall 1995)
| Peter Pan | Eileen Fendler |
| Mr. Darling/Captain Hook | Gary Troy |
| Mrs. Darling/Indian | Leslie Garcia |
| Wendy | Kimberly Abruzese |
| John | Brett Lewis |
| Michael | Brett Fox |
| Liza | Kerry Brown |
| Tiger Lily | Donna Pesce |
| Smee | Miguel Acevedo |
| Pirates | |
| Mitchell Horn | Matt Ravick |
| John Norberto | Anne-Marie Norberto |
| Joseph Zeolla | |
| Lost Children | |
| Shannon Cornale | Amanda Santo |
| Heather Fox | Karina LaGravinese |
| Rachel Coleman | David Heidelberger |
| Peter McLaughlin | Joe Pirone |
| Mike Fries | Eric Thum |
| Indian/Nana | Maria Oluieras |
| Indian/Jane | Jessica Sarbo |
| Indians | |
| Michelle Marie Guido | Nancy Jane Blake |
| Donna Fox | Lisa DiPippo |
